You Googled “how to hire a packaging designer” and landed here instead of some SEO-stuffed article written by a packaging supplier who wants to sell you boxes. Good. Stay.
I’m a packaging designer. I’ve been doing this for 15 years and I’ve seen founders spend more money fixing bad packaging decisions than they ever would have spent doing it properly the first time. I’ve also sat on discovery calls with founders who’ve been burned: wrong colours on 10,000 units, a designer who disappeared mid-project, Fiverr files that looked great on screen and printed like a fever dream.
This is what I wish someone had told them before they hired anyone.
The real question isn’t “how do I find a designer.” It’s “how do I find the right one.”
There’s a version of this story I hear constantly. Founder has a great product. Needs packaging. Finds a designer, either cheap and fast or expensive and pretty, gives them a brief, gets back some files, sends them to the printer, and then something goes wrong.
Sometimes the colours are off. Other times the label doesn’t fit the substrate. Sometimes the design is gorgeous in a mock-up and completely invisible on an Amazon search results page. Sometimes the designer has already moved on to the next job and you’re left on hold with a printer who is telling you, politely but firmly, that this is absolutely not their problem.
Here’s the thing: most of those mistakes happen before the design brief is even written.
Why the $500 designer and the $9,000 designer are solving different problems
Let me be direct about price, because founders ask me this constantly.
The $500 designer is executing. You tell them what you want, they make it look like that, they send you files. That’s the transaction. If you know exactly what you need, the substrate, the dieline, the colour profile, the print process, what’s legally required on the label, what your customer needs to feel in the two seconds they spend deciding whether to pick up your product, then maybe that works. But most founders don’t know all of that. That’s not a criticism. It’s just not their job to know.
The $9,000 designer is thinking. They’re doing the market research before they open Illustrator. Interrogating your brief. They’re asking who is actually buying this, where it’s going to live, what it’s competing against, and whether your instinct about wanting frosted glass and gold foil makes sense for a product at your price point. Often it doesn’t. A premium finish on a product that retails for $18 means your printing quote costs more than your margin. A good designer tells you that before you fall in love with the idea.
See what’s included in a Studio Stoked packaging project
The gap between those two numbers isn’t ego. It’s strategy, print knowledge, and the thing no one talks about: someone who will actually call the printer, fight for your proofs, and make sure what’s on screen is what ends up on your shelf.
The questions your designer should be asking before you ask them anything
Here’s what most “how to hire a designer” articles tell you: ask for the portfolio, check the reviews, make sure they’ve done your category before.
Fine. Do that. But it’s not the thing that separates a good hire from an expensive mistake.
The thing that separates them is this: does the designer ask questions before they start designing?
Not “what colours do you like” questions. Real questions. The kind that make you realise you haven’t thought something through yet.
Questions like:
Where is this product going?
An Amazon listing, a retail shelf, and a DTC website are three completely different problems. On Amazon, your packaging has to work as an 85×85 pixel thumbnail competing against brands with thousands of reviews and established trust. You have about two seconds. The design that looks beautiful blown up on your website will not necessarily stop anyone’s scroll. On a retail shelf, someone picks it up. They turn it over. They feel the weight of it. The tactile decisions matter in a way they simply don’t on screen. These are not interchangeable briefs, and a designer who treats them the same way is going to get one of them wrong.
What’s your minimum order quantity, and does the print finish you want make financial sense at that volume?
Gold foil embossing on 500 units is a very different conversation than gold foil on 50,000. A designer who suggests finishes without asking this question is designing for Behance, not for your business.
Do you need a box, or just a label? For some products, serums, anything with multilingual regulatory requirements, products going into European markets, a box isn’t optional. It’s where the legal information lives. A designer who doesn’t surface this early means you’re potentially redesigning after the fact.
What are the real objections your customer has before they buy? This is the one most designers skip entirely. Pretty packaging gets attention. Packaging that addresses why someone hesitates is what converts. If your product is a castor oil and the number one complaint about castor oils is that they’re sticky and impossible to wash out, that’s not just a formulation problem. It’s a design and messaging brief. Your packaging should be answering the objection before the customer even picks it up.
Who is this for, specifically? Not “women 25-45.” That’s not a demographic, that’s half the planet. Who is she? What’s the trigger that sent her searching for your product? Is it postpartum hair loss, a bleach job gone wrong, a TikTok rabbit hole? The tighter your answer, the more your packaging can speak directly to her. If your packaging is speaking to everyone, it’s reaching no one.
The mock-up problem
Open Behance. Open Dribbble. Scroll through packaging portfolios.
Beautiful, right? Photorealistic renders, perfect lighting, products sitting in fields or on marble countertops. This is what most founders are evaluating when they look at a portfolio.
Here’s what to actually ask: did this go to print?
A mock-up is not packaging. A mock-up is a designer’s idea of packaging, rendered in software, with perfect lighting and zero print constraints. It has never been near a press. It has never had a printer call at 7am saying the cyan is pulling green on the kraft stock and what do you want to do about the 50,000 units currently waiting.
The work that counts is the work that shipped. Ask your prospective designer: what projects in your portfolio have actually gone into production? What print processes have you worked with? Have you ever had a colour proof come back wrong, and what did you do about it?
A designer with real print experience will have real print stories. Not disasters, experience. They’ll know that green is a nightmare to print consistently. That yellow on certain substrates disappears entirely. They’ll know to call the printer before the files go, not after.
See Studio Stoked work that actually went to print
What strategy actually means (and why skipping it is how you end up back here)
Every founder who has been burned by a bad packaging experience has one thing in common: they jumped straight to design.
They had a product, they had a rough idea of what they wanted it to look like, and they found someone to execute that idea. No one interrogated the brief. No one pushed back. The designer said yes, made it look like what was described, sent the files, and took the money.
The result is packaging that is technically correct and commercially useless.
Strategy is where I build trust with a client, because it’s where I ask everything. Not just the obvious stuff. The uncomfortable stuff. The “have you actually thought about what happens when this gets thrown around in an FBA warehouse” stuff, and the “your competitor has 4,000 five-star reviews and you have zero, so your packaging is doing extra work here” stuff.
My strategy documents run 40 to 50 pages. That’s not padding. That’s the answer to every decision that gets made in the design phase: the colour psychology, the typography choices, the substrate decisions, the finish options that make sense at your price point and the ones that don’t. When we get to design, nothing is a guess. Everything is a reason.
The founders who skip this step are the ones who end up back at square one six months later, with a rebrand brief and a significantly lighter bank account.
The printer conversation nobody prepares you for
When your files go to print, someone has to manage that process. Someone has to check the colour profiles. Review the proofs, not on screen but physical proofs, and approve them before the run starts. Someone has to be the person who calls the printer and says the magenta is off and we’re not approving until it’s fixed.
If that person is you, you will lose. Not because you’re not smart enough. Because you don’t speak the language, you don’t know what’s normal variation and what’s a problem, and you have a million other things to do.
A good packaging designer handles this. They take the printer’s number and they become the problem. You don’t have to think about it. You don’t have to learn what a Pantone reference is or why your beautiful sage green is printing khaki. That’s already handled.
One of my clients, a skincare founder launching into the UK market, had a previous packaging experience where the colour proofs came back completely wrong. Wrong colours, wrong finish. Her previous designer had sent the files and considered the job done. No printer calls, no proof review, no follow-up. She was left dealing with a printer who was pointing at the files and shrugging.
That doesn’t happen in a properly managed project. A designer with real print experience knows what to check, knows when to push back, and has everything documented so that when the printer says “not my fault,” there’s a paper trail that says otherwise.
So how do you actually hire a packaging designer?
Ask them what happens after the files are done.
If the answer is “I send you print-ready PDFs and you take it from there,” that’s your answer. For some projects at some price points, that’s fine. But know what you’re buying.
Ask whether strategy is part of their process or an optional extra. A designer who starts with aesthetics before understanding your customer, your channel, your competitive set, and your print budget is decorating, not designing.
Ask them to show you work that went to market. Not mock-ups. Products you can find on a shelf or a listing page right now.
Ask them what they do when something goes wrong at print. The answer tells you everything about whether they’ve actually been through a production process or whether they’ve been living in Illustrator with a Behance portfolio and a dream.
And if a designer agrees with everything you say, never pushes back, never asks an inconvenient question, and just starts designing: run. The best thing a packaging designer can do for your product is the thing you didn’t know you needed. That only happens when they ask the questions you didn’t know to ask.
Studio Stoked is a packaging design studio based in Croatia, working with CPG founders globally. Strategy-led packaging for brands that need to charge more than they currently do.
+ view the comments
