Soda can packaging fails before a designer touches it. I recently sat on a call with founders launching a canned cocktail. Lovely people. Good liquid. Then I asked who it was for, and they said, with total confidence, “everyone.”
It’s not. It never is. And if you design your can for “everyone,” you’ll spend a lot of money on a can nobody in particular picks up.
Here’s what I’d tell any drinks founder before they brief a designer. And before they say the word “Poppi” out loud in a meeting.
“Everyone drinks beer” is not a target market
Their argument went like this: everyone drinks beer, so everyone will drink this.
Sure. But nobody’s drinking the same beer.
Picture the bloke with a Budweiser, watching the game while he fixes his car in the driveway. Now picture someone at a bar asking whether the IPA has notes of jasmine. Same category. Same can, give or take. Completely different humans.
They shop in different places. They trust different things. They’d pay wildly different prices. Hand one of them the other’s can and he’d put it straight back in the fridge.
That’s the job of soda can packaging. Not to appeal to everyone, but to make the right person feel like it was made for them. The wrong person walking past is fine. That’s the filter working.
The pastel soda pile-up
Let’s talk about the elephant in the fridge.
Poppi sold to PepsiCo for $1.95 billion in 2025, and half the industry took notes on the wrong thing. They saw the candy colours, the bouncy type and the fruit floating around the can, and decided that was the formula.
So now the better-for-you soda shelf looks like a pack of highlighters exploded in Whole Foods. Every can is pastel. Every can is cheerful. Every can says the same thing in a slightly different font.
Here’s the problem. When everyone looks the same, nobody gets chosen. You’re not competing with Poppi anymore. You’re competing with forty brands that look like Poppi, and the shopper can’t tell you apart from two metres away.
And before you say it: no, I will not be taking Liquid Death as a reference. If you quote Liquid Death at me in a discovery call, I will scream. Water in a tallboy with heavy metal branding worked because it was first. The fifth brand doing “edgy water” is just water wearing eyeliner.
Copying a winner’s look doesn’t copy their result. It just makes you the tribute act.
Your can has about two seconds to justify its price
Price perception is the bit most founders skip. It’s also the bit that decides whether your margins survive.
A shopper glances at your can for a second or two. In that moment their brain does quick maths: what is this, who is it for, and is it worth the number on the shelf tag? If your packaging says $1.99 and your price says $3.99, you lose. Nobody reads your back panel to be talked round.
Every visual decision feeds that judgement. Colour, finish, type, how much empty space you leave, whether the metal shows through. A crowded can reads cheap. A confident can reads expensive. A can that looks like kids’ candy reads like it should cost the same.
So before anyone talks colour palettes, you need to know what price you’re defending, and who you’re defending it to.
What to figure out before anyone opens Illustrator
This is the part I actually get paid for. Design is the easy bit once you have these answers:
- Who’s drinking it? Not demographics. Where do they shop, what do they read, what’s already in their fridge?
- Where is it sold first? A café fridge, a co-op shelf and an Amazon tile are three very different jobs.
- What’s the price, and what does it need to feel like? Your can has to look worth more than you’re charging.
- What’s the competition doing? So you can go where they aren’t.
- What’s true about your drink and not about theirs? That’s your story. Not “natural flavours.” Everyone has natural flavours.
If you can’t answer those, your designer can’t either. They’ll just make something pretty, and pretty is the most common thing on the shelf.
The production stuff nobody warns you about
A can is not a label slapped on a bottle. It’s a cylinder, and the shopper only sees about a third of it at once. Your front panel has to work alone, and the rest has to work as the can turns in someone’s hand.
Then there’s the decision that shapes your budget more than any design fee: how the artwork gets onto the can.
Printed cans. The artwork goes straight onto the aluminium. Best finish, most premium feel. But minimum orders are high and your colour count is limited. You’re also designing with bare metal as part of the palette, which is gorgeous when planned and muddy when it isn’t.
Shrink sleeves. A printed film shrunk around a blank can. Full 360-degree colour, photographic detail and much lower minimums. Great for launching and testing flavours without warehousing a fortune in aluminium.
Pressure-sensitive labels. The cheapest way in and fine for tiny runs. They can look homemade, though, if the brand isn’t strong enough to carry them.
A real example: when the maths doesn’t add up
I’m currently working on a sparkling flower water. Not a soda, but same can, same shelf, same headaches.
Three flavours at launch. The printed can route meant a minimum of 5,000 cans per flavour. That’s 15,000 cans of stock for a brand that hasn’t sold one yet, with a shelf life of about a year. If one flavour doesn’t fly, you pay to store it and then pay to bin it.
So we flagged it early and recommended shrink sleeves to cut the minimum. Less sexy than talking colour, but it’s the conversation that keeps founders solvent.
This is why I manage print production on every project. Your designer should know what happens after the files leave their desk. If they don’t, you’ll find out at the proof stage, which is the most expensive place to learn anything.
Soda can packaging FAQs
How much does soda can packaging design cost?
It depends on whether you’re buying strategy or just artwork. A freelancer might mock up a can for a few hundred dollars. A full brand strategy, identity and packaging system with print-ready files and production support costs a lot more. My CPG projects start at $12,000 USD. If that number made you wince, read [why packaging design is so expensive](INTERNAL LINK).
Should I use printed cans or shrink sleeves?
Shrink sleeves for launch and testing. Printed cans once you have volume and know which flavours sell. Let your minimums, cash flow and shelf life make this call, not your mood board.
How do I make my soda can stand out on the shelf?
Stop looking at other cans for ideas. Work out who your drinker is, what they’d pay, and what’s true about your drink that isn’t true about the rest. Then design for that one person. Standing out is a side effect of being specific.
Do I need a brand strategy before designing my can?
Yes. Without one, you’re picking colours on vibes and whatever your competitor launched last month. Strategy is what makes every design decision defendable when your buyer, investor or mum asks “why pink?”
The bottom line
Your drink is not for everyone. Thank god. “Everyone” doesn’t have a shopping list, a favourite café or a price they’re happy to pay.
Work out who’s actually drinking it, design the can for them, and make sure it can be printed without bankrupting you. That’s soda can packaging that works.
Launching a drink and want someone to poke holes in it before you spend money on cans? [Here’s how I work](INTERNAL LINK: CPG packaging service page). I’ll ask the annoying questions so your shoppers don’t have to.
+ view the comments

