Packaging Design Mistakes. You’ve got a great product. You’ve done the hard yards. Sorted the formula, found a manufacturer, convinced yourself the market’s ready. And then you slap some packaging on it, launch, and… nothing.
Not because your product is bad. Because your packaging is doing you dirty.
After years of working with CPG founders, from first-time launchers terrified of making the wrong call to founders who’ve already launched and are standing in a metaphorical car park wondering what went wrong, the same mistakes come up again and again. Here they are, unfiltered.
Mistake 1: You Asked Your Followers What They Think
Let me be blunt. Your followers are mostly other founders and your mates from school. They love you. They want you to succeed. They are also completely unqualified to make decisions about your packaging.
They don’t know that neon green won’t print in CMYK. They don’t know what the shelf looks like at 9am in a Whole Foods. They don’t know what your actual buyer (the tired parent, the gym regular, the woman who’ll pay €12 for a protein bar if the packaging tells her it’s worth it) is going to feel in three seconds flat.
Your husband says it looks great because he wants peace in the house. He is not crazy. He just doesn’t want to pick a fight. He is also not your customer.
You wouldn’t crowdsource your tax return. Stop crowdsourcing your brand.
Mistake 2: You Don’t Actually Know Who’s Buying Your Product
This is the one that costs the most money. Not knowing your audience isn’t a branding problem. It’s a revenue problem.
Take Mick. Mick makes a no-nut protein bar. Legitimately great product. And Mick wanted to put it in gyms, targeting gym-goers who train hard and read labels.
The actual buyer? A stressed mum whose teenager carries an EpiPen. She’s throwing snacks into a bag at 3:45pm before the school run. She grabs Mick’s bar because it’s safe for her kid’s allergy group, easy to grab, and she can throw it in the car for post-soccer-practice. She does not care about Mick’s macros.
That’s the person the packaging should speak to. Not the guy doing lat pulldowns.
Nobody cares about your brand story. They care about themselves and what your product solves for them. Design for that person. Specifically, ruthlessly, visually.
If you can’t describe your buyer with the specificity of “tired mum, 38, two kids, soccer schedule, school allergy policy printed and laminated on the fridge” you’re not ready to design packaging yet.
Mistake 3: You’re Planning to Fix It in Round Two
The packaging you launch with is a financial commitment, not a rough draft.
“We’ll fix it in the second batch” is the most expensive sentence in CPG. Because here’s what actually happens: a retail buyer looks at your first run packaging, decides in four seconds it doesn’t belong on their shelf, and says no. They don’t give you notes. They just don’t call back.
And here’s the other thing nobody tells you: you need to design for future SKUs before you’ve even launched the first one. If you launch a single product with packaging that was designed in isolation, adding a new flavour or format six months later turns into a full rebrand. Everything’s slightly off. Nothing quite works together. You end up spending twice.
If the budget’s tight, and everyone’s budget is tight, launch fewer SKUs with better packaging. One product that looks like it belongs on a premium shelf beats three that look like they’re still figuring it out.
Mistake 4: Your Designer Is Charging You $500 and It Shows
Not every designer is wrong for you because they’re cheap. But there’s a reason some designers charge $500 and some charge more.
A $500 designer will do what you ask. They’ll make it look okay on a white background. They’ll hand you a JPEG and wish you well.
They will not tell you that the neon green you’re obsessed with will print as a khaki mudslide in CMYK. They will not tell you that your hierarchy is wrong and customers can’t read the product name from two metres away. They will not tell you that the font you love is unreadable at 8pt on the side panel. They will not think about what happens when you add a second SKU.
Cheap design isn’t just a visual problem. It’s a signal. If I feel like you’ve skimped on the packaging, I wonder what else you’ve skimped on. The packaging is the first thing I touch before I taste your product. If it feels cheap, the product does too. Even if the product is exceptional.
Mistake 5: Your Packaging Looks Great. It Just Doesn’t Look Like Anything.
Čajanka had a Canva logo. It wasn’t ugly. It just felt like it could belong to anyone. There was nothing in it that said: this brand has a point of view, and that point of view is for you.
Mons & Miel makes cakes up to €240. Their founder, Sanja, is not your local mum baking in a kitchen. The business is precise, considered, and beautiful. The packaging had to communicate that before a single word was read. Because if it didn’t, no one’s pulling out their wallet for a €240 cake from someone they don’t trust on sight.
Being generic is not safe. It’s the most expensive mistake on this list because it’s invisible. You think you’ve done the job. The shelf tells a different story.
So What Do You Do About It?
Two options depending on where you’re at.
If your packaging hasn’t launched yet: Do it properly. My Signature Service covers brand strategy, identity, packaging, and the whole system. Designed to hold up across SKUs, retail, and everything that comes after. Projects start at $9k USD.
If you’ve already launched and something feels off: Start with Shelf Shock. One hour. I look at your packaging with seventeen years of context and no reason to be nice. You get a PDF the next day with what’s working, what isn’t, and what to fix first. $400 USD.
And if you’re trying to figure out how to find the right designer before you spend a dollar, I wrote this for you.
Marta is the founder of Studio Stoked, a brand strategy and packaging design studio for CPG founders who need their product to cost more than it currently does. Work with her here.
+ view the comments
